Fuller Upper Lip: What It Means in Face Reading
When the upper lip is fuller than the lower, the less common arrangement. What the shape is, why it stands out, and what face reading says about a top-heavy lip: goodness in Lavater, giving in Jean Haner, charisma, drama and stoicism on modern pages that contradict each other outright.

A fuller upper lip is one that is taller, or projects further, than the lower lip. It is the less common of the two arrangements, which is partly why people notice it and partly why face reading has had so much to say about it. The claims range from goodness to drama to stoicism, often on pages published in the same year.

What does a fuller upper lip look like?
At rest, the red of the upper lip is taller than the lower, and in profile the upper lip may sit a little forward of it. The effect is sometimes described as a pout, although nothing is being done: it is simply the shape.

Is a fuller upper lip unusual?
It is the less common arrangement, not a rare one. In adults the lower lip is usually the thicker of the two: a 3D study of lip shape found the lower lip was thicker than the upper lip across the group, and that upper-to-lower ratios did not differ significantly between the sexes or between age groups. So a fuller upper lip reverses the usual proportion. It is one of many ordinary variations, like a longer second toe.

Does the upper lip change with age?
The upper lip changes most of all. Lips change with time for everyone, and the research is more specific than the usual "lips lose volume" line. Studies of the ageing upper lip found it grows longer while the visible red of the lip shrinks and thins; one found that a loss of volume could not be shown, and a histology study concluded the older look comes from lost elasticity rather than to often-postulated but unproven total volume loss. So a fuller upper lip tends to look slimmer and longer over the decades, as everyone's does.

What does face reading say about a fuller upper lip?
What the folklore says. Four sources account for almost everything said about lips and character. Shen Xiang Quan Bian, a Ming-dynasty Chinese face-reading compilation traditionally credited to the sage Chen Tuan, opens its section on lips by calling them the city wall of the mouth and the gate of the tongue. Johann Caspar Lavater's Essays on Physiognomy (1770s, quoted from Thomas Holcroft's English translation) declares "As are the lips so is the character". Samuel R. Wells's New Physiognomy (1866) reads love and affection in them. And most of what modern pages say, especially about the cupid's bow, traces to the American face reader Jean Haner, whose views are quoted here from an interview about her book The Wisdom of Your Face.
Lavater wrote that "a mild overhanging upper lip generally signifies goodness". Jean Haner reads a naturally fuller upper lip as a giving person, attentive to a partner's needs. Modern pages cannot agree on anything else: one calls a fuller upper lip charismatic, another calls it a drama queen, and a third calls its owners stoics with a humble lifestyle. A Japanese fortune teller's column calls it loving and devoted.
The classical Chinese lines about the upper lip are about family fortune rather than character, and we have left them out. Goodness, giving, charisma, drama, stoicism and devotion: that is six answers to one question.

Is any of that true?
No. We found no study that has tested lip shape against measured personality, in any direction. Research on the wider idea, reading character from faces, finds that people agree quickly and are mostly wrong: a review from Alexander Todorov's lab concluded that the diagnostic validity of these attributions has been greatly overstated.
One study shows neatly what lips really change. Strangers rated before-and-after photos of women who had lip filler, and rated the after photos significantly improved compared to the pre-treatment photographs across all nine trait domains, including trustworthiness and intelligence. The women had not changed. The strangers' guesses had. That is what face reading measures: the reader. Enjoy the box above as history, and as a little fun.
The short version
The upper lip taller or more forward than the lower: the less common arrangement, and an ordinary one. It slims and lengthens with age like every upper lip. The folklore gives six contradictory readings and has tested none.
Sources
- De Menezes et al. 2011, Three-dimensional analysis of labial morphology - read as an abstract.
- Iblher et al. 2008, Changes in the aging upper lip - read as an abstract.
- Penna et al. 2009, The aging lip - read as an abstract.
- Todorov et al. 2015, Social attributions from faces - read as an abstract.
- Othman et al. 2021, The impact of dermal fillers on perceived personality traits - read as an abstract.
- Shen Xiang Quan Bian, section on lips (Chinese, Wikisource)
- Lavater, Essays on Physiognomy, Holcroft translation - "The Mouth and Lips".
- Wells, New Physiognomy (1866) - chapter XI.
- Jean Haner, interviewed in Cosmopolitan India
Comments
Loading comments...