Contraception Methods Compared Side by Side
The implant, hormonal coil and copper coil are over 99% effective even in everyday use. Pills, patch and ring are around 91% in typical use. Only condoms protect against STIs.

There is no single best contraception, only the one that fits you. The NHS compares methods on how well they work, how they are used, side effects and risks, and effects on periods. The most effective with everyday use are the implant, the hormonal coil (IUS) and the copper coil (IUD), each over 99% effective with typical use. Only condoms also protect against sexually transmitted infections.
What does "typical use" mean?
Every effectiveness figure on this page comes in two versions. The NHS explains that "perfect use" means used correctly all the time, and "typical use" includes things like missing a pill, a condom coming off during sex or forgetting to replace a vaginal ring.
The gap between the two is the important part. For methods you do not have to remember, the numbers are the same. For methods you use every day or every time, real life pulls them apart.
How well does each method work?
These are the NHS figures, in its order of effectiveness with typical use:
- Contraceptive implant: over 99% typical, over 99% perfect
- IUS (hormonal coil): over 99% typical, over 99% perfect
- IUD (copper coil): over 99% typical, over 99% perfect
- Contraceptive injection: 94% typical, over 99% perfect
- Combined pill, progestogen-only pill, patch and vaginal ring: 91% typical, over 99% perfect
- Condoms: 82% typical, 98% perfect
- Internal (female) condoms: 79% typical, 95% perfect
- Natural family planning: 76% typical, 91 to 99% perfect, as an estimate
- Diaphragms and caps: typical use unknown, 92 to 96% perfect, as an estimate
The NHS explains what over 99% means: if 100 women chose the implant, less than 1 would have an unintended pregnancy in the first year. Female sterilisation is more than 99% effective.
On withdrawal, the NHS says it is not an effective way to avoid pregnancy and is not recommended.
How often do I have to think about it?
The NHS groups methods by how often you use them:
- Every time you have sex: condoms, diaphragm, cap
- Every day: the combined pill and the progestogen-only pill
- Every week: the contraceptive patch
- Every 3 weeks: the vaginal ring
- Months or years: IUD for 5 or 10 years depending on type, implant for 5 years, injection for 8 to 13 weeks depending on type. The IUS page says the hormonal coil lasts for 3 to 8 years, depending on the type.
- Permanent: female sterilisation and vasectomy
Some you manage yourself after a first appointment, such as the pills, patch, condoms, diaphragm, cap and vaginal ring. Others need a doctor or nurse: the IUD, IUS, implant and injection.
Which methods have hormones, and which do not?
According to the NHS:
- Two hormones, oestrogen and progestogen: the combined pill, the patch and the vaginal ring
- Progestogen only: the progestogen-only pill, the IUS, the implant and the injection
- No hormones: condoms, the IUD (copper coil), the diaphragm and the cap
The copper IUD stops pregnancy by releasing copper into the womb. Sterilisation does not affect your hormones, and you'll still have periods.
What are the side effects?
For hormonal methods, the NHS says commonly reported side effects include headaches, feeling sick, mood swings, weight gain, sore breasts and acne. It then adds something worth knowing: there is not enough evidence to show if these side effects are caused by hormonal contraception. If you do get them, they usually get better within around 3 months, and if they are a problem, a different type of contraception may suit you better.
On risks, the NHS says hormonal contraception can raise the risk of blood clots and breast cancer. The risk is very low, but it means some hormonal contraception is not suitable for everybody.
For non-hormonal methods, the copper IUD can cause pain in your lower tummy or back for a few days after it is fitted, and make periods heavier or more painful, which usually gets better after a few months. With a diaphragm or cap, the spermicide can irritate your vagina, and you may be more likely to get a UTI. There is a small risk of infection after an IUD is fitted, and in the rare event it fails, an increased risk of ectopic pregnancy.
How does contraception affect periods?
This can be a reason to choose a method, not just a side effect. The NHS says if you have heavy or painful periods, you may be offered contraception to treat this even if you do not need it to prevent pregnancy.
- Methods that can make periods less painful: the combined pill, the IUS, the implant and the injection
- Methods that can help with heavy periods: the combined pill, the IUS, the progestogen-only pill, the implant and the injection. The NHS says the IUS is generally the most effective for heavy periods.
- The copper IUD can make periods heavier and more painful, which usually gets better within a few months.
The NHS also says the combined pill can help with acne, heavy or painful periods, PMS and endometriosis.
How quickly does fertility come back after stopping?
It depends on the method. According to the NHS:
- IUD and IUS: fertility returns to previous levels straight away after an IUD is removed, and the same is true after an IUS is removed.
- Implant: your chance of pregnancy returns to what it was before straight away.
- Combined pill: fertility usually returns to previous levels after about a month.
- Progestogen-only pill: it usually takes about 1 month.
- Patch: usually after around 1 to 3 months.
- Injection: it can take up to 1 year.
Which methods protect against STIs?
Only one. The NHS says only condoms can protect against sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, and the WHO says the same: condoms are the only method that also protects against sexually transmitted infections, including HIV. For methods like the copper coil, the NHS says that because an IUD does not stop you getting or passing on STIs, use a condom every time you have sex.
What if contraception fails?
Emergency contraception is available, and the NHS says the IUD is the most effective type of emergency contraception. There is a separate article on the options and time limits. If you cannot feel your IUD threads, the NHS says you might not be protected against pregnancy and may need emergency contraception.
Where can I get advice?
The NHS says to contact a doctor, nurse, sexual health clinic or pharmacist to find out more about the risks of hormonal contraception. The WHO notes that health worker advice can help people identify appropriate contraceptive methods, and that choosing depends on each individual's health, preferences and needs.
The short version
The implant, hormonal coil and copper coil are over 99% effective even with everyday use, because there is nothing to remember. Pills, patch and ring are over 99% with perfect use and about 91% in typical use. Condoms are the only method that also protects against STIs. Side effects and effects on periods vary by method, and some methods can help with heavy or painful periods. A GP, nurse, pharmacist or sexual health clinic can help you choose.
Sources
- NHS, Choosing a method of contraception - the things to compare.
- NHS, Emergency contraception - the IUD as the most effective emergency method.
- NHS, How well contraception works at preventing pregnancy - typical and perfect use figures for each method.
- NHS, How contraception is used - how often each method is used, who gives it, STI protection.
- NHS, Side effects and risks of hormonal contraception - hormonal methods, side effects, evidence, risks.
- NHS, Side effects and risks of non-hormonal contraception - non-hormonal methods, IUD and diaphragm side effects and risks.
- NHS, How contraception affects periods - methods that help with painful or heavy periods.
- NHS, What is the combined pill? - fertility return, other benefits.
- NHS, What is the progestogen-only pill? - fertility return.
- NHS, What is an IUS? - duration, fertility return.
- NHS, What is the contraceptive implant? - fertility return.
- NHS, What is the contraceptive injection? - fertility return.
- NHS, What is the contraceptive patch? - fertility return.
- NHS, What is female sterilisation? - effectiveness, hormones and periods.
- NHS, What is an IUD? - how it works, fertility return.
- NHS, Side effects of an IUD - missing threads and emergency contraception.
- NHS, Natural family planning - withdrawal not recommended.
- World Health Organization, Family planning/contraception methods fact sheet - condoms and STIs, choosing a method.
This article describes what those sources say. It is not medical advice, and it is not a substitute for a doctor, nurse or pharmacist.
Comments
Loading comments...